The gap
Nearly 190,000 households1 here cannot afford an entry-level new home.
Set the entry price of new construction against the local income distribution and the mismatch is roughly 200 households1 for every new home in that price band. The logistics and retail jobs that employ about 18 percent1 of the workforce typically pay $40,000 to $60,0001, which supports a home priced between $198,000 and $296,0001.
HUD reached the same conclusion from a different dataset. Its market analysis of the Indianapolis area found an average new home price of $431,1007 against $293,4007 for an existing home, and while 82 percent7 of existing sales cleared below $400,000, only 53 percent7 of new home sales did. Two sources, two methods, one spread: the homes being built start above the band most of the demand sits in.
The rental side tells the same story from below. Prosperity Indiana and the National Low Income Housing Coalition count 34 affordable and available rental homes3 for every 100 extremely low-income households in Indiana, a statewide deficit of 137,138 units3. Across the metro, average market-rate apartment rent has climbed nearly 50 percent6 in ten years, from about $899 to $1,339 a month.